Debt recovery

Recovery suit or arbitration: choosing the route for a commercial claim

A creditor holding an unpaid commercial claim often has two routes in view: a suit before a commercial court, or arbitration. This article is general information and not legal advice. It sets out the questions a business can ask to decide between them, starting with the contract.

Start with the dispute clause

The first document to read is the contract. If it contains a valid arbitration agreement, the starting point is arbitration. Under Section 8 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, a judicial authority before which a suit is brought in a matter that is the subject of an arbitration agreement must refer the parties to arbitration if a party applies no later than when submitting its first statement on the substance of the dispute, unless it finds that prima facie no valid arbitration agreement exists.

So if you file a suit despite an arbitration clause and the other side applies in time, the suit can be sent to arbitration. Check:

  • Does the clause cover the dispute? Look at the wording on which disputes are included.
  • Is the agreement signed and valid? An unsigned or unclear clause may be contested.
  • What does it say about the seat, the number of arbitrators and the institution? These shape cost and speed.

If there is no arbitration clause, a commercial suit is usually the route, unless a special statute provides a forum.

Appointing an arbitrator

If the agreed procedure for appointing the arbitrator fails, Section 11(6) allows a party to ask the Supreme Court or the High Court, or a person or institution designated by it, to take the necessary measure, unless the agreement provides other means. So a clause that has stalled need not end the claim.

Interim relief

Both routes allow for interim protection. Section 9 of the Arbitration Act allows a party to apply to a court for interim measures before or during arbitral proceedings, or at any time after the award but before enforcement. The relief listed includes securing the amount in dispute and interim injunctions or the appointment of a receiver. In a suit, interim applications are filed within the suit. If assets are at risk, ask early which forum can give you the protection you need.

Time and process

A commercial suit before a commercial court requires pre-institution mediation under Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, unless urgent interim relief is sought. The Supreme Court held the requirement to be mandatory in Patil Automation Pvt. Ltd. v. Rakheja Engineers Pvt. Ltd. (2022). Our article on unpaid invoices in Bangalore covers the earlier steps, such as the demand notice.

Arbitration has its own time provisions. For matters other than international commercial arbitration, Section 29A(1) of the Act provides that the award is to be made within twelve months from the date of completion of pleadings. The Act also provides for a limited extension of that period under the section.

After the decision

An arbitral award can be challenged only on limited grounds. An application to set it aside under Section 34 may not be made after three months from receipt of the award, and the court may allow a further thirty days if sufficient cause is shown, but not later. Under Section 36, once the time to apply to set aside has expired, the award is enforced under the Code of Civil Procedure as if it were a decree of the court. A pending Section 34 application does not by itself make the award unenforceable unless a stay is granted.

A decree in a suit is enforced by execution, and it is open to appeal under the law governing the court.

A comparison you can use

Questions that help decide:

  1. Is there a valid arbitration clause? If yes, expect arbitration.
  2. How urgent is the need to freeze assets or stop a transaction? Check which forum can act, and how fast.
  3. How contested are the facts? A claim based on admitted invoices differs from one about quality and counterclaims.
  4. What does the contract say about costs, seat and arbitrators? These affect the budget.
  5. Is the claim documented well enough for a summary procedure? Order XXXVII suits suit clear written debts.

For how these claims are handled, see our pages on commercial dispute lawyers in Bangalore and arbitration for businesses.

Frequently asked questions

Can I file a suit if my contract has an arbitration clause?

You can file, but if the other side applies in time under Section 8, the court must refer the parties to arbitration unless it finds prima facie that no valid arbitration agreement exists.

How long does a party have to challenge an arbitral award?

Section 34(3) allows three months from receipt of the award, with a further thirty days if sufficient cause is shown.

Can I get interim relief if I choose arbitration?

Section 9 allows a party to apply to a court for interim measures before, during or after arbitral proceedings, until enforcement.

Is mediation required before a commercial suit?

Yes, under Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, unless urgent interim relief is sought.

This article is for general information only. It is not legal advice, and the law and its interpretation change. Please consult an advocate about your specific facts before acting.

Keep reading

Call WhatsApp